By Michael O’Neill
Last weekend Calgary was party-central for Canadian Football League fans. The 113th Grey Cup game was an exciting affair, with six lead changes and played under nearly ideal conditions, leading to an exciting finish.
With 1:07 remaining, Montreal Alouettes head coach Jason Maas faced a game-defining decision. His team needed three yards to keep possession and continue its attempt to win the game. He could leave his offence on the field, trust his quarterback to deliver, or punt and hope his defence would get the ball back with enough time to score.
Maas chose to trust his offence. It didn’t work.
Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem has a different version of the same dilemma. When he meets with the Governing Council for the final policy decision of the year on December 9, he has two choices: pass on raising rates or punt a 25 bp hike.
Unlike Maas, Macklem isn’t up against a ticking clock or a trailing scoreboard. Instead, the Governor is balancing an inflation target, a mixed bag of economic data, and a Canadian economy that could use a little encouragement.
Governing Council Playing a Guessing Game
BoC Deputy Governor Toni Gravelle attempted to explain the Bank’s October rate hike. The decision was based on an earlier high-oil-price scenario. If crude remained elevated and inflation stayed close to 3% for more than a year, consecutive rate increases would be needed to bring inflation back to target.
He failed to explain how making Canadians pay more to borrow money for mortgages, car loans or increase costs to business for capital expenditures would lower the price of oil. It won’t. He failed to explain why the BoC’s oil price forecasting model was more reliable than the Bank’s own inflation measures.
And unlike the Grey Cup game, where the coaches had to deal with a clock running out, the BoC did not bother explaining why it was so urgent to raise rates in October. It’s not like they don’t have a history of allowing inflation to run above or below the target for a period of time. From 2010 until the start of the pandemic, inflation spent most of its time in the bottom half of the 1-3% control range and no one lost sleep over it. Everyone remembers the “transitory era” when soaring inflation rates were dismissed.
Mr. Gravelle played both sides of the street. When the BoC hiked, WTI was trading around $102.00/barrel. Today it is $81.80 thanks to swelling US crude inventories, forecasts for a supply glut in 2027 and downgraded geopolitical risks.
Today, Mr. Gravelle was busy reframing the Bank’s position as being flexible and not committed to its own forecasts. He described them as conditional possibilities, which allows policy to shift direction as things change, which hints at a pause in December.
That is as close as the BoC will come to admitting October’s tightening was a mistake.
The Fed is Playing a Different Game
The Fed appears to be embarking on a prolonged tightening trek. At least traders think so. Two 25 bp rate hikes are priced in for December and January while March is about 50/50. Several policymakers have said that they believe Fed rates need to rise to combat inflation, and the recent CPI, PCE-price index and employment data supports the view.
And the Trump administration is responsible for almost all of the inflation pressures. The White House’s unilateral decision to attack Iran drove oil prices higher and thoroughly disrupted the oil supply chain. Trump’s tariffs have driven prices higher across America. The Democrat “Blue Wave” that washed over the US mid-term elections may rein in some of Trump’s more damaging actions, but the use of executive orders is still a powerful tool.
The Fed’s policy rate currently sits at 4.00%, compared with Canada’s at 2.50%. That 150-basis-point differential in favour of the US dollar may widen further and if so, it will prove to be a serious problem for the Canadian dollar.
The Loonie Getting Sacked
The Canadian dollar looks like a quarterback facing an onrushing defensive line while his O-line steps out for coffee. It knows it is going to get buried. The question is how much? Think Covid-era levels.
Since mid-September, every basis point of CAD/US spread widening has been worth something like eight to ten pips on USDCAD. That’s a rough rule of thumb, but it has held up well enough to take seriously. If the Fed hikes in December and once more early in the new year while the BoC sits on its hands, the two-year spread, currently -148.8 bps, could widen by another 40 to 50 bps. That would blow through the record low of -168.7 bps set in February 2025, the week Trump signed his first tariff order. The last time the spread was anywhere near there, USDCAD was trading at 1.4795.
In this game, it is the Loonie that is going to get punted.

